People search for “coin dealers Parma Ohio” and “coin shops near me” for all kinds of reasons: a jar of old silver coins, a set of proof sets from the 1960s, a gold piece that’s been in a safe deposit box, or a whole collection after a parent passes away. Parma is where my business is based, so this is a question close to home. Here’s an honest look at your options around Parma and Greater Cleveland, and how to pick the right buyer for what you have.
Your options near Parma
Local coin shops
Brick-and-mortar coin shops in Cuyahoga and Summit counties buy and sell coins every day. A good shop can sort bullion from collectible coins quickly. You’ll need to bring your coins in, and hours vary, so call ahead.
Coin shows
Coin shows bring many dealers into one room, which makes it easy to get several opinions in an afternoon. They happen on a schedule, though, so you may wait weeks for the next one, and you’re carrying your coins through a crowded venue.
Pawn shops and jewelry stores
Many will buy silver and gold coins, usually by their metal content. That’s fine for common bullion-type coins, but they may not recognize a scarce date or a high-grade coin.
Online auctions and marketplaces
Selling online can reach more collectors, but you take on photography, fees, shipping, insurance and the risk of returns or disputes. It works best for someone who already knows exactly what each coin is.
A mobile coin buyer
That’s me. I meet you at your home in Parma, Parma Heights, Seven Hills, North Royalton or anywhere in Greater Cleveland, or at an agreed public place. We go through the coins together at your table. The buying appraisal is free, and if you accept my offer, you’re paid on the spot.
How to choose a coin buyer you can trust
- Ask about experience and memberships. I’m an American Numismatic Association Life Member, and ANA members agree to follow the association’s code of ethics. It’s a fair question to ask anyone you’re considering.
- Look for someone who explains the offer. For silver and gold coins, a buyer should be able to show you how the offer relates to the metal content and the day’s spot price.
- Make sure they look at every coin. A buyer who weighs a whole bag without looking may miss a better date or a high-grade coin, in either direction.
- Never feel pressured. You should be able to say no, keep your coins, and owe nothing.
What to have ready
- Leave coins as they are. Don’t clean, polish or dip them. Cleaning can sharply reduce collector value.
- Keep holders and paperwork together. Original Mint packaging, PCGS or NGC slabs, albums and receipts all help.
- Do a rough sort if it’s easy. Separate U.S. from foreign, and pre-1965 dimes, quarters and halves (90% silver) from later ones. My guide to what a 1964 quarter is worth explains why 1964 is the cutoff.
- Snap a few photos. A picture of the whole group plus a few close-ups lets me tell you, before anyone drives anywhere, whether a visit makes sense.
Bullion versus collectible coins
It helps to know which kind you have. Bullion coins and bars, such as American Silver Eagles, Gold Eagles, Maple Leafs and refiner bars, trade mainly on their metal content, so their value follows the spot price (check it on Kitco). Numismatic or collectible coins are valued on rarity, date, mint mark and condition, and some are worth far more than their metal. Most collections are a mix, and part of a buyer’s job is sorting one from the other.
How a coin-buying visit with me works
Start with a call or text to (216) 322-9898. Tell me roughly what you have and send a few photos if you can. If it sounds like a fit, we set a time that works for you, any day of the week by appointment. At the visit I go through the coins with you, point out which are bullion and which may have collector value, and explain how I arrived at my offer. You can sell everything, sell some and keep the rest, or sell nothing at all. There’s no charge for the visit or the appraisal either way.
Selling an entire collection or estate?
If you’ve inherited coins, take your time. Read how to sell an inherited coin collection before deciding anything. For whole households, see my estates page.
Want a straight answer about what you have? Call or text me at (216) 322-9898, or send a message with the form below. The buying appraisal is free, there’s no obligation, and I come to you.
Common questions
Are there coin dealers in Parma, Ohio?
Yes. Parma and the surrounding Greater Cleveland area have coin shops, coin shows, pawn and jewelry stores that buy coins, and mobile buyers like Mister Money Bags, which is based in Parma.
Should I clean my coins before selling them?
No. Cleaning or polishing coins can remove their original surface and lower their collector value. Show them to a buyer as they are.
Do you buy coin collections at my home in Parma?
Yes. Jim Pavlish comes to your home anywhere in Parma and Greater Cleveland, or meets you at an agreed public place. The buying appraisal is free with no obligation. Call or text (216) 322-9898.
