Inheriting a coin collection often comes with mixed feelings. It may represent decades of someone’s hobby, and it can be hard to tell whether you’re looking at a few hundred dollars of pocket change or something much more valuable. After 37 years of buying coins, here’s the step-by-step approach I recommend to families around Cleveland. Most of it applies no matter who you end up selling to.
Step 1: Don’t clean anything, and don’t rush
The two most expensive mistakes I see are cleaning coins and selling in a hurry. Cleaning, polishing or “dipping” coins can strip their original surface and cut their collector value dramatically, even when they look better to you. Leave coins in their albums, folders, flips and plastic holders. There’s rarely a reason to decide in the first week.
Step 2: Make sure you have the authority to sell
If the collection is part of an estate that’s going through probate, the executor or administrator usually controls estate property until it’s distributed. Check with the estate’s attorney before selling, especially if there are several heirs. Keeping everyone informed now prevents disagreements later.
Step 3: Take a simple inventory
You don’t need to identify every coin. A basic list is enough:
- Albums and folders (for example “Lincoln cents 1909–” or “Morgan dollars”)
- Mint sets and proof sets, still in original U.S. Mint packaging
- Certified coins in sealed PCGS, NGC or other grading holders (write down the certification numbers)
- Bullion: silver or gold Eagles, Maple Leafs, rounds and bars
- Rolls, bags and loose coins, including foreign coins
- Paper money
Take photos of each group. Many collectors kept notes or receipts, so keep those with the coins.
Step 4: Understand the two kinds of value
Metal value. Silver and gold coins have a floor value based on their precious-metal content and that day’s spot price (check silver or gold on Kitco). For example, U.S. dimes, quarters and half dollars dated 1964 and earlier are 90% silver; my article on what a 1964 quarter is worth shows the math.
Collector value. Some coins are worth more than their metal because of rarity, date, mint mark, errors or exceptional condition. This is where expertise matters, because two coins that look alike to most people can be worth very different amounts.
Step 5: Do some light research
For certified coins, you can enter the certification number on the PCGS or NGC websites to confirm what the coin is. Their online price guides, and the annual Guide Book of United States Coins (the “Red Book”), give a general sense of values. Remember that those are retail or guide prices. A dealer’s buy price will be lower, because the dealer has to resell the coin.
Step 6: Decide how you want to sell
- All at once to one buyer. Fastest and simplest. Best when you want the estate settled.
- Split it up. Selling bullion to one buyer and key collectible coins elsewhere, or at auction, can sometimes bring more, but it takes more time and effort.
- Keep some. Many families keep a few sentimental pieces and sell the rest. That’s completely reasonable.
Step 7: Choose a buyer who looks at every coin
A fair buyer goes through the collection with you, explains which coins are bullion and which have collector value, and lets you decide piece by piece or as a group. I’m an American Numismatic Association Life Member, and that’s how I work: I come to your home anywhere in Greater Cleveland or Akron, the appraisal is free, and if you accept the offer you’re paid on the spot.
A note on taxes
Inherited property generally takes a tax basis equal to its fair market value at the date of death, and the IRS treats coins as collectibles, which can affect how any gain is taxed. Everyone’s situation is different, so ask a tax professional. Keep a record of what you sold and for how much. (My appraisals are for a possible purchase. They aren’t tax, insurance or probate valuations.)
Want a straight answer about what you have? Call or text me at (216) 322-9898, or send a message with the form below. The buying appraisal is free, there’s no obligation, and I come to you.
Common questions
What should I do first with an inherited coin collection?
Don’t clean the coins and don’t rush. Leave everything in its holders, confirm who has authority to sell if there’s an estate, and make a simple inventory with photos.
How do I find out what an inherited coin collection is worth?
Separate bullion (valued on metal content and the day’s spot price) from collectible coins (valued on rarity and condition). Look up certified coins on the PCGS or NGC websites, use price guides for a general idea, and have an experienced buyer go through every coin.
Do I pay taxes when I sell inherited coins?
It depends on your situation. Inherited property generally takes a basis equal to its value at the date of death, and coins are treated as collectibles. Ask a tax professional for advice.
Can someone come to my house to look at an inherited coin collection in Cleveland?
Yes. Jim Pavlish, an ANA Life Member with 37 years of experience, comes to homes across Greater Cleveland and Akron. The buying appraisal is free with no obligation. Call or text (216) 322-9898.
